Samples / Task 2 essay / Discuss both views / Band 8

The Purpose of Prison: Punishment versus Rehabilitation

An IELTS Academic Task 2 model essay discussing punishment versus rehabilitation in the prison system, evaluated at a Band 8 level.

The question

Some people think that the main purpose of prison should be to punish offenders. Others believe it should be to rehabilitate them so that they can return to society. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

The question of whether prisons should primarily serve as places of punishment or rehabilitation has been a subject of intense debate for decades. While some argue that depriving criminals of their freedom is a necessary act of retribution, others contend that reforming offenders is the only way to ensure they become productive members of society upon release. In my opinion, while punishment is essential to uphold the rule of law, rehabilitation must be the primary focus of modern correctional facilities. On the one hand, proponents of punishment believe that retribution is the cornerstone of justice. When individuals commit crimes, they break the social contract and must face consequences that reflect the gravity of their actions. This approach serves as a powerful deterrent, discouraging potential criminals from engaging in unlawful behaviors out of the fear of incarceration. Furthermore, a strict prison sentence provides a sense of closure and justice to the victims and their families. Without this punitive element, many argue that the legal system would lose its authority and fail to protect the public. On the other hand, advocates for rehabilitation argue that purely punitive measures do little to address the root causes of crime. Many offenders come from disadvantaged backgrounds, suffering from poverty, lack of education, or substance abuse. Simply locking them away without addressing these underlying issues often leads to high rates of reoffending, or recidivism, once they are released. By focusing on rehabilitation through vocational training, psychological counseling, and educational programs, prisons can equip inmates with the necessary skills to secure honest employment and reintegrate into society successfully. This approach ultimately benefits the community by lowering crime rates and reducing the taxpayer burden of maintaining overcrowded prisons. In conclusion, although the retributive aspect of prison is vital for maintaining order and deterring crime, I believe that rehabilitation is far more constructive in the long term. A justice system that prioritizes reform over mere vengeance not only heals the offender but also creates a safer and more harmonious society.

Raised the bandHeld the band downHover a highlight for the note

This answer was written by a language model to a real exam question, then scored by Bandly against the four public band descriptors. The band is a software estimate. No examiner has marked it, and the band a real examiner would award may differ. Scored with google/gemini-3.5-flash on 2026-09-08.

Estimated overall

Mean of the four criteria, rounded the way the exam rounds it.

Task Response 9

You fully address both views and give a clear personal opinion that is consistently developed and well supported, with no part of the task overlooked.

Coherence and Cohesion 7

You have logically organised your ideas with clear progression, but some cohesive devices are used in a slightly mechanical way.

Lexical Resource 8

You use a wide range of vocabulary fluently and flexibly to convey precise meanings, but there are occasional inaccuracies in word choice and collocation that prevent a band 9.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy 7

While you use a variety of complex structures and produce frequent error-free sentences, a few errors in grammar and punctuation prevent a higher score.

What would take this higher

To elevate your Coherence and Cohesion score to a band 8, you should focus on transitioning between paragraphs and ideas more naturally rather than relying on mechanical linkers. For instance, instead of using formulaic transition phrases like "On the one hand" and "On the other hand" to introduce your body paragraphs, you could integrate your contrasting points more smoothly by linking the core concepts of retribution and rehabilitation directly in your topic sentences. By using more sophisticated, paragraph-level referencing and lexical cohesion instead of repetitive signposting, your overall argument will flow much more organically.

Find out what this essay would score

Paste your own answer and Bandly returns an estimated band for each of the four criteria, with the sentences that pulled the score down. Under a cent an essay, about six seconds.

Check my essay

More at this level

Band 8Task 2 essay

Living Abroad: Weighing the Benefits and Drawbacks of Global Migration

An IELTS Academic Task 2 model essay exploring whether the advantages of living and working abroad outweigh the challenges of relocation.

345 wordsAdvantages and disadvantages

Band 7Task 2 essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of Mobile Phones

An IELTS Academic Task 2 essay exploring the pros and cons of mobile phones, written at a Band 6.5 level.

306 wordsAdvantages and disadvantages

Band 7Task 2 essay

Television: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Personal Perspective

An IELTS Academic Task 2 essay discussing the pros and cons of television globally, written at a Band 7 level with typical candidate errors.

274 wordsAdvantages and disadvantages